Damages House: A Blueprint for Building Noneconomic Damages Cases Juries Trust
Christy Crowe Childers
Description
Description
Putting a dollar value on human loss can be one of the hardest things jurors are asked to do. Damages House provides an innovative method for crafting concrete and compelling noneconomic damages cases that juries immediately understand and identify with. Author and trial lawyer Christy Crowe Childers’s new model shows you how to condense complicated legal concepts into a format that is easy for juries to understand. Learn how to empower jurors to fight for your clients with this step-by-step framework for crafting a damages story that is unique, compelling, and effective.
In part one, Childers teaches a foundational approach to developing cases built combining universal concepts and storytelling techniques that are framed in the law and grounded in the evidence–an approach that not only works to invite jurors to fight for your client, it also helps protect your verdict on appeal. Childers also discusses traditional damages models and explores the benefits and shortcomings of each model in particular cases, offering examples of when the traditional models work–and when they do not (and why).
In part two, Childers begins showing you how to adopt the Damages House method based on state and case type. She offers examples of how to root the method in state laws and pattern jury instructions, and what to do when you need something more custom. With a basic framework in place, Childers then demonstrates how to start building your case by using the method to elicit case-changing testimony from your client and witnesses–including ways to inoculate against defense tricks designed to devalue your client’s loss and suffering. You will also learn how to use storytelling techniques to build your case and present your witnesses.
In part three, you will learn how to apply the Damages House method to trial and settlement negotiations. Childers demonstrates how to approach settlement negotiations, mock trials, focus groups, and mediation. You will see how mock jurors use the Damages House model to reach their verdicts both in person and in the big data focus groups Childers uses to quickly test and hone her cases. Childers will then give you everything you need to use the Damages House method in your own focus groups or mock trials so that you can make one last attempt to settle your case before opening day. Childers also discusses how to adapt the Damages House model to wrongful death cases and how these cases should be handled differently.
Finally, you will learn how to use the Damages House method in trial where Childers demonstrates the following:
- How to use Damages House to pick the jurors that are right for your case
- Give your project structure by using visuals to simplify and organize your case
- Adopt the powerful three-step Damages House structure for opening statement
- Use before and after witnesses to take the jury on a guided tour of your Damages House during direct examination
- Take on the hardest defense witnesses in cross-examination
- Keep jurors’ attention and avoid turning them against you
- A step-by-step guide to tying it all together in closing argument
Damages House offers plaintiff’s lawyers an opportunity to create winning cases in an innovative and elegant manner that makes the harm your client has suffered real and tangible for the jury. As Childers puts it, “It’s not just about numbers; it’s about justice.”
Author
Author
Details
Details
Publisher: 312 pages; 1st edition (2027); ISBN: 9781951962883
Paperback: Trial Guides, LLC
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
Publisher’s Note
Acknowledgments
Foreword
Introduction
The Problem in a Nutshell
The Last Straw
The Epiphany
How this Book is Organized
- The MUSE Method
- Making an Epiphany
- But First, Let’s Find Your Muse
- Ingredient #1: Mindset
- Ingredient #2: Universals
- Ingredient #3: Story
- Mix Well and Serve
- Conclusion
- Buy Used or Build New?
- New Things Are Scary
- Step One: Thank Your Brain
- Step Two: Pause Your Brain
- Buy Used
- Brief Description of Each Traditional Model
- Build New?
- Conclusion
- New Things Are Scary
- What Type of House Will You Build?
- Choice 1: Spec Home—The Perfect (or Near Perfect) Pattern House
- First, Let’s Simplify your Jury Charge
- Going Through the Process
- Next, Make Sure Your Spec House Feels like Home
- Custom Built Home
- When the Rooms are Hard to Picture
- Conclusion
- Choice 1: Spec Home—The Perfect (or Near Perfect) Pattern House
- Damages House Depositions
- Let your Client Solve Your Damages Problems. 77
- Before and After Witnesses. 82
- Have a Damages Specialist 83
- Show them the House. 83
- Dirty Defense Tricks at a Damages Deposition. 86
- Defense Tricks Targeting Noneconomic Damages. 91
- Conclusion. 96
- Plot Mapping
- The Victim’s Plot Map
- Plot Points
- Exposition: Back Story
- Inciting Incident: Becoming Who They’re Meant to Be
- Pre-Injury Conflict: Set Back
- Pre-Injury Rising Action: Overcame that Obstacle
- Main Conflict: Negligence Causes Injury—Map the Villain’s Plot
- Post-Injury Rising Action
- Climax: Verdict
- Falling Action: How Money Can Help
- Resolution: The Ending
- Conclusion: From Plot Map to Damages House
- Filling the Rooms: Casting Call, Renovations, and Witness Order
- Archetypes
- The Missing Archetype. 130
- Simple Casting. 131
- Advanced Casting. 133
- Putting It All Together 142
- Decide Who Wins Each Room.. 145
- Renovations. 145
- Witness Order 146
- Sequencing with Acts 148
- Conclusion. 151
- Archetypes
- The Appraisal
- Appraisal Methods. 154
- Method #1: The Simple Multiplier Method. 154
- Method #2: Scaling. 157
- Method #3: The Dollar Amount 171
- Method #4: Range. 172
- Method #5: Economic Damages Exceptions 173
- Method #6: Combining Methods. 175
- Conclusion. 177
- Appraisal Methods. 154
- Settlement Negotiations, Mock Trials, Focus Groups, and Mediation
- Please Don’t Give Away the Farm
- Demands and Settlement Negotiations
- Mock Trials/In Person Focus Groups
- Online Big Data Focus Groups
- The Write Up: Noneconomic Damages
- The $11 Million Ask
- The $33 Million Ask
- How to Use Damages House in Mediation Without Giving Away the Farm
- Conclusion
- Wrongful Death Damages House
- Death is Different
- Blueprint #1: The Happy Life Method
- Happy Life Method: Example 1
- Happy Life Method: Example 2
- Blueprint #2: The Perfect Pattern Method
- Blueprint #3: The Values Method
- The Values Method in Action
- Blueprint #4: The Empty House—Baby Death Cases
- Blueprint #5: The Last Damages House—Elderly Death Cases
- Blueprint #6: Dementia Damages House—When their Last House is a Memory Care Home
- Conclusion: Putting It All Together
- Trial Begins: Jury Selection
- Jury Selection
- The Three Damages Questions You Must Ask in Jury Selection
- Explain the Difference Between Economic and Noneconomic Damages
- Damages Bias Inquiry #1: Willingness to Assign Value to Noneconomic Damages
- Damages Bias Inquiry #2: Upper Limits Bias
- Damages Bias Inquiry #3: Capacity for Empathy
- Six Bonus Questions to Conclude
- Conclusion
- Visuals
- Damages House Visual
- Main Timeline
- Vertical Causation Timelines
- Family Timeline
- Conclusion
- The MUSE Opening Statement
- Framework
- Truth: We Always Begin with an Undeniable Truth
- Humanize
- Safe System / System Failure
- Plot Map
- Bulletproofing
- Damages House
- Learn the Damages House Opening
- Step 1: Introduction (Economic versus Noneconomic Damages)
- Step 2: Frame It in the Law (Judge Gives Law—We Bring Evidence; More than Pain and Qualifying Language)
- Step 3: Ground It in the Evidence (Stories)
- The Ask: Appraise
- Conclusion
- Framework
- Direct Examination
- Note Card Out Your Direct
- Witness Preparation and Fortification
- Presenting your Direct Examination at Trial
- Conclusion
- Cross-Examination: The MUSE Method
- Pre-Trial
- Step 1: Get Your Mind Right (Mindset)
- Step 2: Find Three Truths (Universal Truth)
- Step 3: Give the Jury Villains to Choose From (Storytelling)
- The MUSE Cross-Examination in Action
- Conclusion
- Pre-Trial
- Closing Argument
- The MUSE Closing Argument
- First Closing
- First Closing Example
- Final Closing
- Final Closing Example
- Conclusion
- Final Thoughts
- The MUSE Closing Argument
